Puffiness and discoloration for good

If you’re one of the many women who think eye creams are just another way for the cosmetic industry to get you to buy more skin care products, dermatologist Kenneth Beer, MD, PA, says you should reconsider. The skin around your eye is the thinnest layer of skin on your entire body, and therefore the most sensitive, he says. So using a cream made specifically for your eyes is crucial, especially as you age.

Skip ahead to see the 12 best eye creams now.

“Eye creams can, and often do, show results if they are used appropriately and for a long enough time,” says Beer. The trick is to find the best eye cream for your skin’s needs. If you feel like you’ve been duped by the hundreds of eye creams on the market promising to erase your dark circles, puffiness and fine lines, you probably haven’t tried the ones on this reader-approved list. Our reviewers have tested all the potions, creams, and elixirs for the delicate eye area and boiled it down to these 12 eye creams that actually work. Ready to become an eye cream believer?

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 7.4*
Why it’s great: Reviewers call this eye cream “amazing,” “very effective” and a “must-have.” One reviewer says it “absorbs quickly, isn’t greasy” and keeps her eyes looking “fresh and young.” While many reviewers acknowledge its high cost, they find that it is “ultimately worth the money.”
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.0*
Why it’s great: This eye treatment “de-puffs and soothes instantly,” thanks to the metal rollerball applicator. “It feels wonderful going on,” says one reviewer, who also claims it has “smoothed [her] skin and lightened the under eye shadows [she] had.”

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.2*
Why it’s great: Reviewers say this eye gel is “amazingly cooling, soothing and de-puffing … helps with a hangover or general tiredness showing up around your eyes.” One reviewer says that her eyes look “brighter and much younger” after using this product. For extra de-puffing benefits, another reviewer stores hers in the fridge. Overall, they say it’s a “miracle gel.”